So, you’re dreaming about the Amalfi Coast (who isn’t?), but now you’re staring at Google Maps thinking: Do I book a stay in Positano, Amalfi, or Ravello? Classic problem. Each town looks like it popped straight out of a postcard, but trust me—they couldn’t be more different once you’re actually there.
I’ve done the “eenie-meenie-miney-mo” approach before (spoiler: I picked Positano that time), and later realized I might have been happier staying in Ravello. Yep—this choice matters. And that’s why I’m breaking it all down for you.
Let’s figure out which Amalfi town is truly your match.
Why This Decision Actually Matters
Here’s the thing: the Amalfi Coast is not easy to get around. The roads are winding, buses are crowded, and boats only connect certain towns. So where you choose to stay shapes your whole experience. Do you want nightlife and cocktails by the sea? Or peace and quiet on a cliff with nothing but lemon trees for company?
Pick right, and you’ll never want to leave. Pick wrong, and… well, you’ll probably still love it (because Italy), but you’ll also be slightly annoyed every day.
Positano: The Glamorous Starlet
What’s It Like?
Imagine Instagram exploded and became a town—that’s Positano. Bright pastel houses tumble down cliffs, bougainvillea spills over balconies, and every corner looks like it’s begging to be photographed.
It’s beautiful, yes. But it’s also the busiest and most expensive spot on the coast. Think: designer boutiques, five-star hotels, and Aperol spritzes that cost more than your lunch.
Who Will Love Positano?
- Couples on a romantic getaway (honeymooners, this is your jam).
- Travelers who want buzz, nightlife, and chic beach clubs.
- Anyone whose dream is sipping cocktails in a flowy dress while a live band plays Dean Martin in the background.
Pros
- Stunning views at literally every turn.
- Great nightlife—bars, beach clubs, and restaurants galore.
- Easy boat connections to Capri and other towns.
Cons
- Pricey AF (you’ll feel it in your wallet).
- Can get packed with day-trippers.
- Stairs. Endless, calf-burning stairs.
My Take
I loved Positano for the energy—it’s glamorous and vibrant. But IMO, two or three nights max is plenty before you start craving quieter vibes.
Amalfi: The Historic Heart
What’s It Like?
Amalfi is the town that gave the coast its name, so yes, it’s iconic. Compared to Positano, it’s flatter (thank you, universe), and more about history and culture than nightlife. Picture cathedrals, piazzas, and a slower pace.
It’s also better connected transportation-wise, which makes it an excellent base if you want to explore multiple towns without pulling your hair out.
Who Will Love Amalfi?
- Families (fewer stairs, easier logistics).
- History buffs who geek out over ancient cathedrals.
- Travelers who want a balanced mix of activity, restaurants, and a little peace.
Pros
- Cultural gems like the Amalfi Cathedral.
- Better transport links (buses, ferries).
- Slightly more affordable than Positano.
Cons
- Still touristy, though not as flashy as Positano.
- Beaches aren’t as glamorous—think pebbles, not sand.
- Less nightlife compared to Positano.
My Take
Amalfi feels like the “just right” middle child. You don’t get the full-on glam of Positano or the secluded romance of Ravello, but you get a solid balance. Perfect if you want the Amalfi experience without committing to one extreme.
Ravello: The Quiet Dreamer
What’s It Like?
Ravello sits high above the coast—no beaches here, just jaw-dropping views. It’s quieter, more refined, and often described as the soul of the Amalfi Coast. Think classical music festivals, historic villas, and peaceful gardens.
If Positano is champagne and Amalfi is wine, Ravello is herbal tea with honey—you come here to relax.
Who Will Love Ravello?
- Honeymooners who want peace (without the chaos of Positano).
- Artists, writers, and daydreamers looking for inspiration.
- Anyone who prefers relaxation over nightlife.
Pros
- Unreal views (seriously, Villa Cimbrone’s Infinity Terrace is mind-blowing).
- Calm and quiet—great for recharging.
- Gorgeous villas and gardens to explore.
Cons
- No direct beach access (you’ll need to bus or drive down).
- Fewer restaurants and shops compared to the other towns.
- Very quiet at night—if you want action, look elsewhere.
My Take
Ravello is magic. If you’re looking for tranquility and don’t care about beaches, this is the place to be. I’d pair a few nights here with Positano or Amalfi for the perfect trip.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Here’s the quick cheat sheet so you don’t overthink it:
Positano
- Best for: Glamour, nightlife, couples, “the vibe.”
- Downside: Expensive and crowded.
Amalfi
- Best for: Families, history buffs, balance.
- Downside: Not as glamorous or quiet.
Ravello
- Best for: Peace, romance, views.
- Downside: No beaches, less nightlife.
FAQs
Q: Which town has the best beaches?
Positano wins here. The beach scene is chic and lively. Amalfi has pebbly beaches, and Ravello doesn’t have direct access.
Q: Can I visit all three towns in one trip?
Yes, and you should! They’re all close, but IMO it’s best to stay in one and day-trip to the others.
Q: Where should I stay if I don’t have a car?
Amalfi is your best bet since it has the best transport connections.
Q: What’s the most romantic option?
Tough call, but Ravello has that serene, tucked-away vibe. Perfect for honeymoons.
Final Thoughts
So, Positano vs Amalfi vs Ravello—which Amalfi town is right for you? Honestly, it comes down to your travel style. Do you want energy and glam (Positano), balance and history (Amalfi), or peace and views (Ravello)?
If you can swing it, split your time: a few nights in Positano for the buzz, then retreat to Ravello for calm. That’s the dream combo IMO.
Oh, and one last thing—if you’re planning your trip, don’t forget travel insurance. I once had a ferry cancellation that almost stranded me (fun times), but having coverage saved me. I usually recommend this travel insurance option because it’s affordable and reliable. Better safe than sorry, right?
Wherever you end up, trust me—you’ll be sipping limoncello, staring at the sea, and wondering why you didn’t book a one-way ticket.